Cam and Cheese

 
             | 
Home Point and Shoot Canon SD1100IS vs Nikon S550 vs Sony DSCT70 Comparison

Canon SD1100IS vs Nikon S550 vs Sony DSCT70 Comparison

E-mail
User Rating: / 2
PoorBest 

I recently got to use the Canon PowerShot SD1100IS, Sony CyberShot DSC-T70 and the Nikon CoolPix S550. All three are in the $250-$300 price range of sleek and think point and shoot cameras. They have either 8MP or 10MP sensors, and they all have image stabilization in one form or another. Here's a comparison of all three to help you decide which one to get.

To see each individual review please read the following articles:

Specs

MakeCanonNikonSony
ModelSD1100ISS550DSCT70
Price (MSRP)$280$260$300
Price (Purchase)$230$235$270
Resolution8MP10MP8.1MP
Optical Zoom3x5x3x
35mm Equivalent38-114mm36-180mm38-114mm
Image ProcessorDiGiC IIIEXPEEDBiONZ
LCD2.5"2.5"3" Widescreen Touchscreen
Image StabilizationOpticalelectronic VROptical / Super SteadyShot
ISO160020003200
Minimal Focusing
Distance
1.2 inch4 inches1 inch
Dimensions
w x l x h (mm)
8.68 x 5.49 x 2.209 x 5.35 x 2.29 x 5.64 x 2.1
Weight (g)125120128
ColorsRhythm & Blue, Swing Silver, Pink Melody, Bohemian Brown and Golden TonePurple, Black and BluePink, Black, Silver or White

Functions

Movie ModeYesYesYes
Smile ShutterNoYesYes
Blink WarningNoYesNo
Smile MeterNoYesNo
Panoramic/Photo StitchYesYesNo
Interval ShootingNoYesNo
Burst ModeYesYesYes
Color Modes B&W, Sepia, Vivid, Cyanotype 
Scene Modes 1610
Paint ModeNoNoYes
Spot FocusingYesYesYes
Color SwapYesNoNo
Color AccentYesNoNo

Each of these cameras has its problems in both the body and its functionality. Here's a brief explanation of what I thought.

Camera Body

Canon PowerShot SD1100IS

This camera is light weight. They added a groove in the front for your middle finger which really helped make it more comfortable to hold. The camera is very balanced. The biggest problem with the body I had with the SD1100IS is that for some reason they made the buttons flush with the camera. They don't protrude out, so for people with chubbier fingers, it is harder to press. Aside from that, I had no complaints about the body. It has the best battery door of the bunch. Just push down and slide and it's closed. Very easy.

Nikon Coolpix S550

I honestly think the S550's body was the least friendly. Yes it is the shortest, and weighed the least. But, my biggest problem with the camera is that to preview pictures the lens had to come out. I don't understand that. You should have a switch similar to Canon's where you can move it to preview mode, and then turn it on to look at your pictures. The lens doesn't have to be used when previewing pictures, so I don't understand why it has to come out. Secondly, the battery door is the clumsiest one I've ever used. It just won't go in so easily. You'll usually slide it closed crookedly with it half in and half out. It's probably due to the very thin plastic. Also, the tripod mount was on the far left of the camera. This camera is also the widest, so when on a mini tripod the balance was definately bad. This camera did have the BEST quality LCD in my opinion. It had the best viewing angle, and had the least amount of noise when looking at dark areas. I also don't like the zoom buttons. But, maybe it's just because it's different from what I'm used to.

Sony CyberShot DSC-T70

I think the Sony looks the best. The lens doesn't pop out so it's less likely to break if you drop the camera, yet it still provides 3x optical zoom with its Carl Zeiss Vario-Tessar lens. The camera has a massive 3" widescreen touchscreen LCD, and makes very good use of it. There are literally just three physical buttons on the camera (I count the zoom slider as one button). This camera also has a bit of a clumsy battery door as you actually have to lock the door back in place. It doesn't automatically look when you close it. The biggest problem I have with this camera is the placement of the lens. It's in the top corner of the camera where your fingers may be. Let's just say I've taken a lot of pictures with my finger in the way. This takes a bit of getting used to, especially if you hold your camera with two hands.

Features

Canon PowerShot SD1100IS

The PowerShot has the least amount of innovation. But it performs well in the features it has. The optical stabilization (which was my main purpose for getting one) works very well. It offers some features that aren't available on the other cameras such as Color Swap and Color Accent. They are fun to play with but not very important. It has a photo stitch function which is very basic. It can't compare to the photo stitch function on the Nikon.

Nikon Coolpix S550

Nikon has a big list of new features. Smile shutter, blink warning, interval shooting, photo stitch, and over 16 scene modes, to name a few. The Photo Stitch is great because you have the ability to stitch left and right AND up and down creating huge pictures. The S550 has a bunch of features that are weak though. The eVR doesn't work all the time. Just when it chooses to. I didn't work when I thought it would, such as at slow shutter speeds. VR or image stabilization plays a huge roll in these reviews, because it's my main reason for upgrading my current point and shoot. The macro mode on this camera is also weird. It continuously focuses, creating a weird noise, and most likely a waste of battery. I just want my camera to focus when I want it to. Whenever I press the shutter down. In summary, it has a lot of features, but some work well, and some don't.

Sony CyberShot DSC-T70

This camera makes great use of its Touch Screen LCD, and offers some fun features. The menu is very easy to use. The optical stabilization works as its supposed to, and reduces the effects of camera shake in your pictures. It has a Paint program so you can customize and draw on your pictures. It also has a smile shutter mode, but the one on the Nikon is better. It doesn't have a panaromic mode which some people like. One of my favorite features is the use of the touch screen to select your focus point quickly.

The Winner - Sony CyberShot DSC-T70

The CyberShot just had the best features, and was the most innovative. Sure the Nikon has 5x optical zoom, but what good is that if the VR doesn't even work properly. When zoomed, the camera shake is amplified. Sony really made good use of the touch screen LCD. It is, however the most expensive.

Runner Up - Canon PowerShot SD1100IS

The PowerShot is strong, but it just didn't offer much innovation. It's the same old Canon camera, that performs well.

Loser - Nikon Coolpix S550

Believe me, I'm a BIG Nikon Fanboy. But, the camera just didn't live up to expectations. The Nikon S550 does have lots of cool features, and some of them perform very well. eVR may very well be the worst image stabilization ever. I have no clue why they didn't just opt for the optical VR. There is a Nikon S600 which does use optical image stabilization, and costs the same as the Sony at $300. When I can get my hands on it, I'll add that camera to this, as it may be a better comparison because of the price.

If you have any questions, feel free to ask, and I'll do my best to answer.




Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Reddit! Del.icio.us! JoomlaVote! Google! Live! Facebook! StumbleUpon! Yahoo! Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!


Comments
Add New Search
jeff.dude  - s550   |2008-10-22 00:33:36
for S550:

if you turn on the camera and then press the view button then the
lense will come out.

if you hold down the view button for like 2+ seconds, you
can enter the view mode..

you can either

press power to turn it off
or press
view button again to use the camera to shoot.

eVR doesn't always work.. lots of
blurr picture taken from using S550.
deetree   |2008-10-20 17:05:18
avatar your welcome! the canon is being sold at a really good price right now - $200 in
canada, so probably even cheaper in the states.

The only thing i'd like on the
SD1100IS is to have more zoom and wider lens. Other than that, it's a pretty
good camera. But the sony just offers so many cool features, unfortunately it
doesn't have the color accent.
ruflie  - tnx   |2008-10-14 18:06:29
Dude that was Sooo helpful
tnx a LOT
i luv my camera (konica minolta G400
but sum girl hit n... i dont like to talk about it
n ive bin lookin 4
a new camera 4 a while n this helped a LOT
im still torn between the
canon and the sony tho
ive always wanted a canon but the sony duznt look
half bad either
the reason y i wanted the canon in the first place
was for the color accent feature, if only the sony had that id get it hands
down
Write comment
Name:
Email:
 
Website:
Title:
UBBCode:
[b] [i] [u] [url] [quote] [code] [img] 
 
 
:angry::0:confused::cheer:B):evil::silly::dry::lol::kiss::D:pinch:
:(:shock::X:side::):P:unsure::woohoo::huh::whistle:;):s
:!::?::idea::arrow:
 
Please input the anti-spam code that you can read in the image.

3.26 Copyright (C) 2008 Compojoom.com / Copyright (C) 2007 Alain Georgette / Copyright (C) 2006 Frantisek Hliva. All rights reserved."

 
Add to Technorati Favorites